6 Reasons Not to Buy an Asscher Cut Diamond

A Good Asscher Cut Diamond is Hard to Find

Most diamonds aren’t quite as rare as they’re made out to be. There are over a quadrillion tons of diamonds deep inside the earth, a trillion dollars worth of diamonds locked up in baby boomer safes and deposit boxes, and a near-endless supply of lab grown diamonds being produced right now.

But unless there’s a diamond in your family with your name on it, all the kajillion diamonds out there won’t make it any easier or less expensive to find the perfect stone for your engagement ring.

Diamonds are not actually rare, so supply and demand govern the specifics of the market.

Round brilliant cut diamonds are constantly being churned out, and almost all diamond cutters know how to cut them perfectly, so it’s be incredibly easy to find a quality round diamond.

Asscher cut diamonds, on the other hand, are uniquely difficult to find. Only 2% of diamonds are cut into Asschers, so finding one that has the perfect combination of carat, quality, and price is going to test your patience.

If you’d rather have more than a few options to consider or don’t have all the time in the world to find the perfect diamond, we rest our case. If having something truly unique and difficult to find is worth the extra effort for you, by all means, aim for an Asscher.

To Love an Asscher Cut Diamond, You Need to Love Art Deco

The graphic lines and geometric forms of an Asscher Cut are trademark Art Deco. The emerald, Asscher, and baguette diamond became wildly popular during the movement. Platinum and white gold replaced the soft yellow gold tones of the period’s predecessor, Art Nouveau.

In the words of Rob Sutton, “It was the style of the flapper girl and the factory, the luxury ocean liner and the skyscraper, the fantasy world of Hollywood and the real world of the Harlem Renaissance. Art Deco affected all forms of design, from the fine and decorative arts to fashion, film, photography, transport, and product design. It was modern, and it was everywhere.”

If this era of history doesn’t excite you, it’s going to be hard to get excited about an Asscher cut diamond. They’re a vintage cut.

If, on the other hand, the romance of yesteryear is something you crave, prepare yourself for more disappointment and read on, or follow your heart and shop Asscher cut engagement rings.

Asscher Cuts Tend to be Poorly Cut

First things first, there are not very many Asscher cut diamonds on the market. To make this even more of a pain, most are poorly cut.

Generally, they are too deep or have poor symmetry. Poor symmetry is a big problem for the Asscher cut, because it is more apparent than almost any other diamond shape.

Look at the table of the diamond head-on, where the pavilion tapers to form the culet. You’ll see a windmill pattern formed by the pavilion. They should “kiss.” If they don’t come neatly to the same point, it’s going to annoy the heck out of you. 

If you’re not sure how to evaluate or need some help, you can ask for an ASET. We can provide this for almost any stone listed on our website.

The Asscher Diamond Isn’t Super Super Sparkly

This is the biggest hurdle for most Asscher-curious shoppers. They do flash and refract light to create the colors we call fire. But they just aren’t that sparkly. This is especially true when you compare them to a round brilliant, oval, cushion, or even a trillion cut diamond.

This is because Asschers are a step-cut diamond. Their facets are a series of parallel, mostly rectangular shapes. Compared to the diagonal faceting of brilliant cuts, step cut diamonds have a less sparkly and more orderly appearance.

For some, the Asscher cut diamonds have an understated and sophisticated look. Well-cut Asscher diamonds throw bright, colorful flashes of light, and create a mesmerizing hall-of-mirrors effect.

The Asscher Cut Lets it All Hang Out

Asscher cut diamonds show their color and clarity more than brilliant cut diamonds. Remember the Four Cs? All four of them are annoyingly important with Asschers.

Their large table is like a clear window that shows off inclusions to anyone that cares to look. Inspect the certificate carefully to make sure any inclusions are located away from the main table.

An Asscher diamond’s deep shape accentuates its color. This is because there’s more material for light to pass through. We recommend shopping G and above if you’re planning to set your stone in white gold or platinum.

Asscher Cut Engagement Rings are $$$$

If you’ve made it this far, congratulations. You are truly Asscher afflicted.

But there’s one more problem we haven’t covered: painful economic reality. Rare things cost more. If you can find an Asscher you love, you’re going to pay a pretty penny. The price per carat of an Asscher is often more than 10% higher than other diamond shapes. They’re a pricey shape for three reasons.

1. Asscher diamonds are difficult to cut. They have the most facets of any diamond cut. 72 facets means 72 opportunities for mistakes.
2. The Asscher cut diamond often wastes more rough diamond material in cutting than other shapes, and that goes into their cost.
3. Asscher diamonds look smaller than other diamonds of similar carat weight, so you’ll probably need a bigger Asscher.

Asscher Cut Diamonds Have Big Bottoms

Depth. Deep Asschers are so common because cutters are trying to make them as heavy (read valuable) as possible. Deep Asschers are going to appear smaller than they should, and stick up higher on your finger. You’ll also be paying for carat weight you won’t see. If you’re considering an Asscher, consider booking an appointment with a Frank Darling concierge who can help you keep track of all the factors you’ll need to be mindful of when selecting an Asscher.

The Asscher Cut is Prone to Windowing

Symmetry isn’t the only place an Asscher cut diamond can take an ugly turn. Like your apartment or house, Asscher diamonds have windows which, of course, allow light to pass directly through the stone.

The best way to assess windowing? An ASET Test.

An ASET test is designed to help color code the light performance of a diamond. It looks a bit like a kaleidoscope. Red is the best. It means maximum light return. Green is the second best. Green areas will show both white and black highlights, creating contrast. Blue is bad and indicates some light leakage. Black is the worst, indicating total light leakage. 

These types of issues aren’t listed on the cert so you’ll have to dig into the weeds if you want to find a great stone. Want us to do the work? Just ask. Or get started by browsing our inventory of more than 150,000 diamonds.