30.010.24

How to Not Get Spooked by Online Engagement Ring Stores

Let’s be real for a second: shopping at online engagement ring stores can feel like stepping into a haunted house—you’re excited, but also low-key terrified of what could pop out at you. Will the ring look as stunning in person? What if it gets lost in transit? And, hello, you’re about to spend thousands on something you’ve never even seen up close. Spooky, right?

But here’s the thing: it doesn’t have to be a nightmare. These days, just about anything—from houses to cars to jewelry and more—can be purchased with a few simple clicks. And the fact is, more and more couples are turning to online engagement ring stores because, when done right, it can be a totally stress-free experience (and often more affordable than brick-and-mortar jewelers, too). So, before you run kicking and screaming, let’s demystify the whole process.

Common Concerns When Shopping at Online Engagement Ring Stores

You’re not alone in being worried about online shopping for something as special as your engagement ring. No one wants to get scammed. Here are the most common concerns people have:

Fear of getting scammed

No one wants a diamond that turns out to be glass or a “gold” band that’s actually… not.

An oval solitaire yellow diamond sits against a white backdrop — Always shop from online engagement ring stores that offer certified diamonds. And bonus if certification is from GIA, IGI, or GCAL.

A beagle mix sits in front of a table that holds two ring display cases — Want to see your ring IRL at the FD HQ? You might expect to also see a dog or two!

Not seeing the ring in person

Will it be as stunning IRL as it is in those perfectly lit photos? Is there even a real photo?

Return policy confusion

What if you’re not happy with it? Will they accept a return, or is it a final-sale horror show?

A two tone emerald cut solitaire engagement ring is slipped on a finger — No return policy? Big problem. Only shop from online retailers that provide a clear return policy.

A blue velvet ring display case with tens of sparkling diamond rings - available in person and at online engagement ring stores — A package getting lost in the mail is every online buyer’s nightmare. Add on the fact that most engagement rings aren’t exactly cheap (though there are workarounds) and you’re talking total night terror.

Shipping anxiety

What if your precious cargo gets lost or damaged on the way? Talk about a nightmare.

Reassurance time: These fears are valid, but they’re also avoidable with a little bit of research and strategy. Let’s dive into how you can make sure your online shopping experience is as chill as possible.

Tip 1: Research and Choose Reputable Online Engagement Ring Stores

The first step to banishing your engagement ring fears? Do your homework. There are plenty of reputable jewelers out there, it’s just knowing how to separate them from the scams. Here’s a few things to keep in mind:

Certifications matter

Look for diamonds certified by trusted third-party labs like GIA or AGS. These are the real MVPs of diamond grading, so you know your stone is legit.

An old-mine cut diamond sparkles with compass claw prongs — Even antique old-mine or old-European cut diamonds can receive certifications! They’re just the best way to know exactly what you’re buying when you buy a diamond ring.

The back view of a nature-inspired Marquise solitaire engagement ring — Be sure to look for engagement ring and diamond reviews and testimonials from platforms that naturally lend themselves to crowdsourcing opinions. That way, you can be sure the company you’re considering hasn’t doctored reviews in any way.

Customer reviews are your bff

Read testimonials like your engagement depends on it (because, honestly, it does). If a store has loads of glowing reviews, that’s a good sign.

Return policies and warranties

Make sure there’s a clear return policy. You don’t want to be stuck with a ring you’re not crazy about.

A person tries on an emerald cut solitaire engagement ring from our Try at Home kit — Many retailers *(cough, us)* also offer care plans or lifetime warranties.

The back view of a platinum solitaire emerald cut diamond engagement ring — When you make a purchase online, you want to be sure that you are protected from all sides. Just like wanting to see your engagement ring from all angles.

Secure payment options

If the website isn’t SSL encrypted (you’ll see a little padlock icon by the URL), don’t do it. You want to make sure your payment info is safe.

Tip 2: Understand the 4Cs of Diamonds (Cut, Color, Clarity, Carat)

You’re not just buying any piece of jewelry—you’re buying a diamond. So, knowing the 4Cs is critical. They’re what determines diamond pricing and can help you choose what’s important to you, and what fits your budget. Here’s the breakdown:

Diamond cut

This affects how sparkly your diamond will be. You want maximum sparkle, obviously. Only round diamonds have industry-standard cut grading. Other shapes are often listed with cut grades, but these can be more fluid and vary from one retailer to the next, so get to know the ideal proportions of the different shapes you’re interested in as well.

A radiant cut three stone diamond engagement ring — Diamonds come in all sorts of shapes but that doesn’t mean each shape receives the same grade. Or that it can even receive a grade.

A black diamond with four flanking baguette diamonds — Is a black diamond considered a colored diamond? Not really, primarily due to the black color resulting from diamond inclusions instead of trace elements.

Diamond color

Basically, less color means more money. Until you get to fancy color, where the inverse is true.

Diamond clarity

This refers to the presence of inclusions (or lack thereof). Fewer and smaller inclusions = more money. But shopping for an “eye clean” diamond can save you serious cash. That means a diamond might have inclusions but they’re not noticeable to the untrained, unaided eye. So you’re not spending money on stuff you won’t see.

A salt and pepper pear cut diamond — Unlike black diamonds, which are completely covered in inclusions, salt and pepper diamonds are peppered with them.

A hand presents four cushion cut diamonds in various sizes — A diamond’s carat weight is often seen as the least important characteristic of a diamond. So go with a weight that speaks to your true heart’s (and budget’s) desire.

Diamond carat

This is a diamond’s weight, not its size. That weight can be distributed quite differently from one diamond to the next, even if they’re the same carat weight. This is why cut is so important. A heavier (higher carat weight) diamond can be a big, dull rock if the weight isn’t cut properly.

Here’s the secret: most reputable online diamond stores will let you inspect the diamond up close with 360° videos or high-def images. Use those tools, and bookmark a few diamond guides to keep handy while you shop.

Tip 3: Use Online Engagement Ring Stores Virtual Try-On Tools or Ring Size Guides

Even if you’re comfortable with making a big purchase online, it can be hard to picture what a ring will look like on your hand. But the future is now. Many online diamond retailers offer virtual try-on tools that let you upload a pic of your hand and “try on” rings. It’s like Snapchat filters but way more important. You can also use sizing guides to make sure you get the perfect fit. Most online stores have detailed instructions on how to measure your size at home. Trust me, this is way less stressful than it sounds.

A hand holds an opened ring box with an emerald cut diamond set on a half-eternity baguette band. An opened blue box is in the background — With our Try at Home kit, you’ll receive three stunning rings of your choice to wear, pair, and stare at – all in the comfort of your home.

A split shank, half bezel set engagement ring with Marquise cut diamond — The Celeste | Marquise

A split shank, half bezel set engagement ring with trillion cut diamond — The Celeste | Trillion

Tip 4: Customize Your Engagement Ring to Suit Your Style

One major perk of shopping online? Customization. Instead of only being able to shop the inventory a jeweler might have on hand, online shopping for engagement rings often provides endless options, allowing you and your partner to design a ring that feels 100% you.

Choose your metal

Yellow gold, white gold, rose gold, platinum—whatever vibes with your style.

A half bezel rose cut rose gold engagement ring — Rose gold is often overlooked but never out of vogue.

A seven stone step cut diamond engagement ring — Love step cuts? Sure there’s emerald, but there’s also baguette, Asscher, and Carre.

Pick your stone and setting

Want a fancy shape diamond or added side stones? Go wild.

Design from home

You don’t even have to leave your couch to create something completely one-of-a-kind. So pop a cork, kick back, and relax.

Ab emerald cut five stone diamond engagement ring — Believe it or not, it’s totally possible to customize your engagement ring completely at home. Drop us a line at hello@frankdarling.com to kick-start the process!

Tip 5: Be Wary of Discounts That Seem Too Good to Be True

We all love a good deal, but if the price is so low that it feels sketchy, trust your gut. You don’t want to save a few bucks only to end up with a ring that screams “fake.” Look for red flags, speak with a human, check for bad reviews, look the business up… if it feels off, then be ready to walk away.

Getting in touch with customer service (they should be clearly and easily able to reach) can also help answer any questions and give you some comfort that there are real humans behind the brand.

How to Ensure Safe Shipping and Handling

So, you’ve found the ring. But now you’re worried about it getting lost in the mail. Totally fair! Make sure that your package is well insured for the full value of your purchase and comes signature required with tracking. This will give you peace of mind as you wait for your precious cargo. No one wants a pricey purchase left at the front door for all to see! If you’re not sure you’ll be home, have it shipped somewhere else secure, like your office or a secure drop box for pickup later.

An open ring box sits next to an opened navy blue box — While it’s annoying waiting all day to sign a package, it’s totally worth ensuring that your diamond gets to you safe and sound. And remember, engagement ring insurance is worth it!

Customer Support: The Secret Weapon of Online Stores

Here’s something you might not know: online stores often have even better customer support than physical shops. You can chat with experts, schedule virtual consultations, and get help with everything from sizing to customization.

Live chat

Got questions? Most online retailers offer live chat with experts who can guide you through the entire process.

A chunky pear cut diamond solitaire engagement ring — Want even more personalized advice? Schedule a virtual consultation for in-depth deep dives on all things diamonds.

A work bench with pen and paper. A newly designed diamond engagement ring is worn — Whether you’re looking for a halo or solitaire, cushion or emerald, our diamond experts can help you design your dream ring.

Virtual consultations

Can’t decide between two rings? Book a virtual consultation and get advice tailored just for you.

You Don’t Have to Get Spooked—Buy With Confidence

Buying an engagement ring online can feel intimidating at first, but it doesn’t have to be a horror show. As long as you know what to look for, it can be an enjoyable (and even fun) experience. From checking certifications to using virtual try-ons, you’ve got all the tools to find the perfect ring without leaving your couch.

Ready to make a move? Explore Frank Darling’s engagement ring collection and see why buying online can be a total dream. You can also schedule a virtual or in-person consultation to chat with an expert, view diamonds, and get help designing the perfect ring.

FAQs

Why are online engagement rings cheaper than in-store?

Online retailers often don’t have the same overhead and inventory costs as physical stores, which means lower prices for you.

A solitaire Moissanite engagement ring — Often, online stores also offer diamond alternatives like white sapphire or Moissanite. Purchasing a diamond alternative can help further cut down on engagement ring costs and save you big.

A diamond artisan placing the final touches on the Celeste band — Think of customer reviews like personal safety checks for your engagement ring.

How do I know if an online diamond store is legitimate?

Look for third-party reviews, customer reviews, and diamond certifications from reputable labs like GIA or AGS.

What’s the safest way to pay for an engagement ring online?

Always use a secure payment method, like a credit card, and look for SSL encryption on the website.

A yellow mug is held by a hand wearing many wedding bands — When shopping online, a little vigilance can go a long way.

A round brilliant asymmetric diamond engagement ring — As we mentioned before, it’s best to fully understand the return policy of the diamond retailer you’re shopping from. That way, you don’t only get a stunning diamond ring-you also get peace of mind.

Can I return an engagement ring if I don’t like it?

Most reputable online stores offer return policies but always double-check the details before purchasing.

A large three stone diamond engagement ring is worn — How to Actually Buy a 10 Carat Diamond Ring

A round brilliant halo engagement ring — How to Buy an Engagement Ring

A kite set Asscher cut engagement ring — Is a 1 Carat Diamond Ring Right for You?

A round brilliant diamond engagement ring — Want to Design an Engagement Ring Online? It’s Easier Than You Think

Stephanie Dore

Stephanie is a jewelry lover, gemologist, and seasoned copywriter with a decade of experience in e-commerce and tech. A RISD graduate, Stephanie also studied at GIA and has worked in the jewelry industry for 20 years. When not writing about diamonds and jewelry, Stephanie is also a photographer and backyard flower farmer. She lives in Tacoma, WA with her two black cats.

Share